As a USDA Certified Organic Farm, we have to follow the NOP rule regarding the purchase of organic seeds.
to wit:
Per the NOP Rule §205.204, the producer must use organically grown seeds, annual seedlings, and planting stock (i.e. onion sets, potatoes, sweet potato slips, and strawberry plugs): Except….. • Nonorganically produced, untreated seeds and planting stock may be used to produce an organic crop when an equivalent organically produced variety is not commercially available, Except, That, organically produced seed must be used for the production of edible sprouts; • that have been treated with a synthetic substance on the NOP list – and none are currently listed
The rule is attempting to close the organic loop by starting with certified seed. However, as everyone acknowledges there aren’t very many organic seed producers (yet) and there are not a ton of organic varieties, either OP or hybrid, that have some of the best disease resistance, flavor, consumer appeal, growing response and so on. When we can’t find it as an organic variety in our favorite catalog, we have to search at least two others (the actual requirement calls for letters, faxes, emails to suppliers, but really, would Johnny’s leave their organic varieties out of the catalog, only to- surprise!- provide them to the grower who sends a letter?). Finally, we document the whole process if we don’t find that variety or a similar one in organic clothes and end up with a conventionally grown variety, justifying the process & result. We all know that limited supply means higher prices and the organic seed market is no exception. But high price is not an accepted reason for purchasing conventional (is the thinking that growers can pass the price on? Not sure, but our customers don’t have an organic purchase requirement…).
For example: I’ve successfully grown Ailsa Craig Onions for years; an excellent sweet onion that sizes up, tastes great, grows well in our systems and people buy. So I look at Fedco for AC, but no organic. I turn to Johnnys, but no organic AC. I try High Mowing and bupkus. Decision time. Do I order AC, justify the search & selection and hope I don’t get dinged for it, which in some cases means having seed orders pre-approved if you want to maintain certification. OR do I drop AC, select a completely new and untested variety (for me) and hope it all works out. In this case, I’ll reduce our order for conventional AC and try Siskiyou Swt Walla Walla from High Mowing (all their seeds are organic). And document the process.
Times almost 200 varieties of stuff.
So, you can see where it’s slightly annoying to be selling at markets where many claim to be organic, just not certified or way sustainable (meaning organic, just not certified, wink/nudge) or buy anything, treated or not, but just not from Monsanto as if it’s the same thing as adhering to the NOP.